Skip to content
NewGot a product? Test it with real Nigerians on 9jatesters
RANKED
Add business

IkejaLagos State

Updated 1 day ago

Best Insurance Companies in Ikeja

Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd and AIICO PENSION MANAGERS share the highest rating at 4.4 stars, with 17 and 26 reviews respectively. Old Mutual leads on review volume: its 4.1-star score comes from 89 reviews, more than three times AIICO PENSION MANAGERS' count. The scores are close. Ikeja, Lagos State, has 11 insurance companies in the ranking. Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd has 4.3 stars from 29 reviews, while Cornerstone Insurance Plc has 4.2 stars from 17 reviews.

How the algorithm scored this11 businesses ranked

Share on WhatsApp

As of September 2026, Ranked lists 11 insurance companies in Ikeja, Nigeria, ranked by review sentiment, reputation and verified activity, never by payment.

Source: Ranked (ranked.ng) directory database · full statistics · methodology

Ranked
11

businesses

Reviews analyzed
227

Google reviews

Photos verified
7

cover images

Last refresh
1d ago

editorial review

How to choose safely

What to check before choosing insurance companies in Ikeja

Rankings are a starting point. For this category, these are the checks that most often separate a useful recommendation from a risky one.

  • Confirm details

    Call or WhatsApp before visiting to verify hours, address, pricing, and availability.

  • Use recent signals

    Recent reviews, fresh photos, and active contact channels are stronger trust signals than old star ratings.

  • Report problems

    If the listing is wrong, closed, unsafe, or duplicated, use the report link so Ranked can review it.

11 results
  • Editor's Selection#1 in the city
    1
    Photo of Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd

    Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd

    63.3/ 100
    4.34.3 out of 5 stars29 reviewsNAICOM-licensed · Insurance broker

    97 Allen Ave, Allen, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    Review analysis

    Customer-centric and professional service with fast handling of inquiries.

    • customer centric
    • professional
    • fast service
    • reliable
    • calm environment
    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗Website ↗
    Why ranked #1? ▾
    • Google rating83
    • Review volume49
    • Review recency4
    • Profile completeness100
    • Review sentiment93
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • MEKUDI I. ★★★★★ : A lovely place and environment
    • Olomola A. ★★★★★ : An insurance brokers company of repute. Have rest of mind dealing with Hilltop insurance
  • 2
    Photo of Cornerstone Insurance Plc

    Cornerstone Insurance Plc

    61.6/ 100
    4.24.2 out of 5 stars17 reviewsNAICOM-licensed · Composite insurer

    6B Adeniyi Jones, Ikeja, 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    Review analysis

    Open on holidays for enquiries, with security and a large building.

    • legit
    • big building
    • small parking
    • open on holidays
    • security
    • beautiful space
    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗Website ↗
    Why ranked #2? ▾
    • Google rating80
    • Review volume42
    • Review recency23
    • Profile completeness100
    • Review sentiment82
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Michy L. ★★★★★ : One of the best insurance company there is.
    • Olarinde D. ★★★★★ : Beautiful space. Coronation insurance also sits on this building.
  • 3
    Photo of Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd

    Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd

    61.4/ 100
    4.44.4 out of 5 stars17 reviewsNAICOM-licensed · Life insurer

    95 Opebi Rd, Opebi, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    Review analysis

    Returned investment from acquired Metropolitan Insurance, showing reliability in mergers.

    • investment plans
    • reliable
    • insurance policies
    • savings
    • protection
    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗
    Why ranked #3? ▾
    • Google rating86
    • Review volume42
    • Review recency53
    • Profile completeness33
    • Review sentiment86
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Adewale A. ★★★★★ : Tangerinelife insurance ,the best insurance policy ever. Save, invest and protectection with life insurance policy.
    • Steve E. ★★★★★ : Great place for your insurance needs
  • 4
    Photo of Old Mutual

    Old Mutual

    60.0/ 100
    4.14.1 out of 5 stars89 reviews

    74 Allen Ave, Allen, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗Website ↗
    Why ranked #4? ▾
    • Google rating77
    • Review volume65
    • Review recency1
    • Profile completeness100
    • Review sentiment50
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Chigozie E. ★★★★★ : Good Customer Service. The Staffs are Nice and Friendly. Neat Offices and Surroundings. A Good Insurance company that offers different kinds of insurance packages to suit your needs.
    • Albert O. ★★★★★ : Old Mutual Nigeria Limited debited my account even after signing the surrender form and my investments terminated.They asked for proof of debit and i sent the bank statement as a proof,the customer care keep saying we are processing it for weeks,the money still not refunded.They have bad customer relations in query resolution.Litigation loading because this is fraud
  • 5
    Photo of AIICO PENSION MANAGERS

    AIICO PENSION MANAGERS

    55.8/ 100
    4.44.4 out of 5 stars26 reviews

    2 Oba Akran Ave, Ikeja, 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗
    Why ranked #5? ▾
    • Google rating86
    • Review volume48
    • Review recency0
    • Profile completeness67
    • Review sentiment50
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Chris A. ★★★★★ : Ample car park area even for wheel chair
    • Ademayowa A. ★★★★★ : Aiico Pension Managers Limited is located on Oba Akran, Ikeja just beside Aiico Insurance. This is One of the best pension managing company in Nigeria owned by Aiico Insurance company.
  • 6
    Photo of AXA Mansard Allen Ikeja

    AXA Mansard Allen Ikeja

    54.3/ 100
    4.24.2 out of 5 stars35 reviews

    15/17 Opebi Rd, Allen, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    Review analysis

    Fast travel insurance processing in under 10 minutes.

    • polite staff
    • prompt service
    • clean ambience
    • good parking
    • helpful customer care
    Directions ↗
    Why ranked #6? ▾
    • Google rating80
    • Review volume52
    • Review recency1
    • Profile completeness33
    • Review sentiment78
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Information I. ★★★★★ : Good and friendly. Car parking facility is good too considering that it's a busy commercial neighbourhood.
    • Temitayo S. ★★★★★ : Polite staffs and prompt service. Got me travel insurance sorted in less than 10mins.
  • 8

    LIB Insurance Brokers Limited

    52.4/ 100
    4.34.3 out of 5 stars3 reviewsNAICOM-licensed · Insurance broker

    12B Ogundana Street, Off Allen Ave, Allen, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗Website ↗
    Why ranked #8? ▾
    • Google rating83
    • Review volume20
    • Review recency33
    • Profile completeness67
    • Review sentiment50
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Temitope A. ★★★★★ : It is a business hub for insurance companies
  • 9

    Dove Insurance Brokers Limited

    49.4/ 100
    5.05.0 out of 5 stars3 reviewsNAICOM-licensed · Insurance broker

    56 Opebi Rd, Opebi, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    WhatsAppCallDirections ↗
    Why ranked #9? ▾
    • Google rating95
    • Review volume20
    • Review recency1
    • Profile completeness33
    • Review sentiment50
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Jegede F. ★★★★★ : Great customer service and always ready to assist when it comes to your insurance claims.
  • 10

    Silverlane Insurance Brokers

    43.7/ 100
    5.05.0 out of 5 stars1 reviewsNAICOM-licensed · Insurance broker

    20 Ogundana St, Allen, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    Directions ↗
    Why ranked #10? ▾
    • Google rating95
    • Review volume10
    • Review recency1
    • Profile completeness0
    • Review sentiment50
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

  • 11
    Photo of Capital Express Assurance Ltd

    Capital Express Assurance Ltd

    28.3/ 100
    3.03.0 out of 5 stars5 reviews

    47 Toyin St, Omole Phase 1, Ikeja 101233, Lagos, Nigeria

    Directions ↗Website ↗
    Why ranked #11? ▾
    • Google rating27
    • Review volume26
    • Review recency2
    • Profile completeness67
    • Review sentiment50
    • Verification0

    Scores 0 to 100 per dimension. See how we rank.

    Recent reviews

    • Innocent N. ★★★★★ : Where claims are processed expressly
    • Austin O ★★★★★ : They are indeed good at what they do

What the data shows for insurance companies in Ikeja

Counted from every insurance company ranked in Ikeja, Lagos State, not only the ones shown above.

Ranked
11
With 5+ reviews
7
Rated 4.5 or higher
2
Median reviews
17
Phone listed
8 of 11
Opening hours listed
4 of 11

7 of the 11 insurance companies ranked in Ikeja have five or more Google reviews, and between them they carry 227 reviews.

Of the 11, 2 score 4.5 or higher, 8 sit between 4.0 and 4.4 and 1 are below 4.0.

The median insurance company here has 17 reviews.

Old Mutual has the most, 89 at 4.1, followed by AXA Mansard Allen Ikeja (35) and Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd (29).

8 list a phone number, 6 a website and 4 opening hours; 7 have a photo on file.

Across the 20 Nigerian cities where Ranked publishes insurance companies, the median city lists 23; Ikeja has 11, fewer than the median.

The most recent Google review we hold for this set is from May 2026.

Source: Ranked directory database, counted at publish time. Full statistics.

Frequently asked questions

Which insurance company in Ikeja has the highest Google rating?

Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd and AIICO PENSION MANAGERS are tied at 4.4 stars. AIICO PENSION MANAGERS has 26 reviews, while Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd has 17 reviews. The shared rating does not come from the same volume of feedback.

Which Ikeja insurance company has the most Google reviews?

Old Mutual has the largest review count, with 89 reviews and a 4.1-star rating. Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd follows on review volume with 29 reviews and 4.3 stars. Review volume measures how many people posted feedback, not competence or financial performance.

How many insurance companies are ranked in Ikeja?

Ranked counts 11 insurance companies in Ikeja, Lagos State. Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd, Cornerstone Insurance Plc, Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd, Old Mutual and AIICO PENSION MANAGERS occupy the first five positions.

Are the Google ratings for Ikeja insurance companies close?

Yes. Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd and AIICO PENSION MANAGERS each have 4.4 stars, Hilltop Insurance Brokers Ltd has 4.3, Cornerstone Insurance Plc has 4.2, and Old Mutual has 4.1. Their review counts vary from 17 to 89.

How should I compare ratings with different review counts?

Read the score alongside its review count. AIICO PENSION MANAGERS has 4.4 stars from 26 reviews, while Old Mutual has 4.1 stars from 89 reviews. Cornerstone Insurance Plc and Tangerine Life Insurance Ltd each have 17 reviews, with ratings of 4.2 and 4.4 respectively.

More in Ikeja

Insurance Companies elsewhere

For business owners

Own or manage a insurance company in Ikeja?

Get a Featured placement: a clear "Featured" label plus an enhanced profile. We never sell rank order; featuring is a label only, and your position in the ranking doesn't change.

Get featured →