Looking for the best ice cream shops in Makurdi, Benue State? Whether you're craving a cool treat on a hot day or planning a sweet outing, we've ranked 18 ice cream spots to help you decide. Leading the list is Tito Gate Restaurant and Cafe with a 4.1-star rating from 617 reviews, while JO Cakes Confectionery boasts the highest rating at 4.8 stars. Our rankings are based on Google ratings, review volume, profile completeness, and other factors to give you a reliable guide.
As of August 2026, Ranked lists 11 ice cream shops in Makurdi, Nigeria, ranked by review sentiment, reputation and verified activity — never by payment.
Esther N.★★★★★ — She is just amazing, I got her from google and she delivered my cake both neatly and on time . So calm and understanding
Thank you a lot am glad
mary O.★★★★★ — This cake was sooo good! Soft, moist, and perfectly sweet — every bite was a treat! And the baker? Super sweet, friendly, and clearly loves what she does. Definitely coming back for more! 🍰💕
Francisca P.★★★★★ — It was cool and the dj played chill music, it’s a nice outdoor spot with drinks and peppered fish, pepper soup and lots more and the customer service was good because they were honestly nice
James T.★★★★★ — Nice meals with great ambiance
Chilled drinks now available 24/7
Sewuese B.★★★★★ — JZee Confectioneries specialises in making bespoke cakes for all occasions, chops, gift packs, baking and Confectioneries. They are professional trainers in baking and cooking.
Their products are yummy!
L. Z.★★★★★ — Such amazing service and cakes. They are really artistic with their cakes and the best cake I've had
Gideon-Faj O.★★★★★ — They have the best food so far that I have tasted. Though I don't like the way the customer service dress. It's too seductive. My opinion though. Also the customer service is a bit not okay for me. There's a lot of process to follow to even get your pre-ordered food.
Blavo S.★★★★★ — Good customer service,my friend was served small meat 😂😂,neat environment
Irozuoke A.★★★★★ — The service here is amazing... The charming smile that greets you and the promptness in delivering your order is so heart warming. I am sure visiting again even if it's for my yummy ice-cream again. The ice-cream was so yummy and served with so much love I could feel it. The meat pie isn't left out.
Ruthie's is your families choice for a good family time in a cool and love filled environment.
Yinusa E.★★★★★ — Serene Environment. The food was good. A cool place to relax.
Terrence T.★★★★★ — Always deliver late still got shawarma with spoilt chicken twice always mixing up orders got food poisoning
Agatha O.★★★★★ — Food prices here are fair and affordable.
A plate of rice can be gotten from 1,000 naira above.
Chilled drinks are served here with pastries as well
Frequently asked questions
Which ice cream shop in Makurdi has the highest rating?▾
JO Cakes Confectionery holds the highest rating among ice cream shops in Makurdi with 4.8 stars from 27 reviews. It is ranked second on our list.
What is the most reviewed ice cream shop in Makurdi?▾
Sudo Pee Supermarket has the most reviews with 679 ratings, earning a 4.2-star average. It is ranked fourth on our list.
Is Tito Gate Restaurant and Cafe a good place for ice cream in Makurdi?▾
Yes, Tito Gate Restaurant and Cafe is the top-ranked ice cream shop in Makurdi with a 4.1-star rating from 617 reviews. It also has a moderate price level of 2.
Are there any ice cream shops in Makurdi with a perfect rating?▾
None of the listed ice cream shops have a perfect 5.0 rating. The highest is JO Cakes Confectionery at 4.8 stars.
How many ice cream shops are ranked in Makurdi?▾
We have ranked 18 ice cream shops in Makurdi, Benue State. The top five include Tito Gate Restaurant and Cafe, JO Cakes Confectionery, Balcony Night Club, Sudo Pee Supermarket, and D. O. Brothers Supermarket Branch.
Get a Featured placement — a clear “Featured” label plus an enhanced profile. We never sell rank order; featuring is a label only, and your position in the ranking doesn’t change.